2017: Returning to Utah for his first professional season in his home state, Peay played in 21 matches making 18 starts. Peay added two goals and an assist to solidify his presence on the USL Regular Season Champion’s backline.
2016: Played in two matches with the Timbers while making one start.
2015: Won MLS Cup with the Timbers in a 2-1 triumph over the Columbus Crew. Featured in five matches with the Timbers during the season, making three starts.
2014: Drafted by the Portland Timbers in the second round of the 2014 MLS SuperDraft (26th overall). Was subsequently loaned to Orange County Blues where he made his professional debut in March of the same year.