Acquired: Selected in 2018 MLS Re-Entry Draft Stage 1 on December 14, 2018.
2020 Real Salt Lake: Toia started 19 of his 20 appearances at left-back for Real Salt Lake in the 2020 season. He recorded one assist in 1,674 minutes.
2019 Real Salt Lake: Toia started at left back in all 24 of his appearances for RSL. Toia recorded one goal, one assist and 31 tackles in 2,323 minutes played.
2017-2018 Orlando City: Prior to the 2017 season, Toia moved to Orlando City SC in the Expansion Draft and started 32 of his 34 appearances.
2015-2016 Montreal Impact: After one season with Chivas, he moved to the Montreal Impact in the 2014 MLS Dispersal Draft. He held the starting left back position for two seasons with the Impact, starting 44 of his 48 appearances and scoring his lone goal. In 2015, he started in all six Knockout Round matches during Montreal’s run to the CONCACAF Champions League Final.
2014 Chivas USA: Upon his return to MLS, Toia started 24 matches out of his 27 appearances for Chivas USA.
2013 Phoenix FC: Toia appeared in 22 matches for Phoenix FC where he recorded six goals and two assists in 1,979 minutes.
2012 FC Tucson: Toia signed as Real Salt Lake’s first homegrown player in 2011 but was released before ever appearing for the club. Instead, Toia joined FC Tucson and scored four goals in 14 matches.
International Career (USA)
2008-2011: Toia made four total appearances for the United States at the U-18 and U-20 levels.